The Superannuation Tax Time Bomb
The Superannuation Tax Time Bomb
Why the Division 296 Tax Threatens Your Retirement Future
Imagine you’ve got a toy box, and inside it are a bunch of your favourite toys.
Every year, your parents check how much fun your toys are worth.
One year, they say your toys look super fun, so they tell you, “We’re taking 15% of your toys away because they’re worth too much fun.”
But here’s the trick — you didn’t even trade them or get new ones.
They just looked more fun. Then next year, some toys get broken. You finally try to sell them and only get a few jellybeans. But you’ve already paid the “fun tax” when your toys were at their peak!
Sound unfair?
That’s exactly what’s being proposed for superannuation with the Division 296 tax.
What Is the Division 296 Tax?
The Australian Labor Government wants to introduce a new tax policy called Division 296. It proposes that anyone with more than $3 million in their superannuation fund will pay an extra 15% tax on their investment earnings — even if they never sell those investments.
Let’s break it down:
Threshold: $3 million total super balance.
Tax: 15% additional tax on earnings above $3 million.
Earnings include: Profits you haven’t actually received yet — called unrealised capital gains.
Starts: July 2025 (if enacted).
Indexation: None. That $3m threshold doesn’t rise with inflation.
You could be taxed for money you haven’t made yet — and might never make at all.
Realised vs Unrealised Capital Gains
Realised Gain = You buy an investment and later sell it for more. You get the profit in your hand. That’s fair game for tax.
Unrealised Gain = You buy an investment, its value goes up, but you don’t sell it. The money’s not in your bank account. You haven’t seen a cent.
Under Division 296, the government wants to tax you as if you sold it and made that money.
If the market crashes? Tough. You’ve already paid tax on phantom money that never arrived.
Why This Is a Dangerous Precedent
1. It Breaks a Foundational Tax Principle
Taxing people on money they haven’t received? That’s new ground — and dangerous.
2. It Creates Liquidity Nightmares
What if your super is invested in property or infrastructure? You can’t just sell a brick wall to pay the ATO.
3. It Could Spread
What starts in super might spread to other areas: shares, investment properties, small businesses. Once the line is crossed, it’s hard to redraw it.
The Misconception – "It Only Affects the Rich"
Labor and many journalists say, “Only 80,000 people will be affected.”
Here’s the truth bomb: anyone who earns a decent income and contributes to super over 40+ years could be caught.
Take this example:
Starting age: 21
Salary: $60,000 (with 3% annual increases)
Super Guarantee (SG): 12%
Investment return: 7% p.a.
By age 65, that worker could have around $3.07 million in super.
That’s not a millionaire. That’s a teacher, tradie, or nurse who worked hard, saved well, and trusted the system.
The Erosion of Trust in Super
Australians have long trusted the super system to be stable, reliable, and based on fair rules.
But what happens when the rules shift?
They start taxing money you haven’t touched.
The goalposts change mid-game.
The threshold isn’t indexed — so it creeps up on more of us.
Result?
People lose faith.
They look elsewhere.
They disengage.
That’s toxic for a system that relies on confidence and long-term planning.
The Youth Are the Most at Risk
Here’s the cruel irony:
The 60-year-old with $2.9 million today? No worries.
The 25-year-old with $60k salary and 40 years of compounding? Taxed.
And since the $3m threshold doesn’t rise with inflation, it becomes easier and easier to breach it.
A $3 million balance in 2065 = around $1 million in today’s dollars.
That’s not rich. That’s a reward for saving consistently and doing the right thing.
The Illiquidity Trap
Super funds invest in things like:
Infrastructure
Property
Private equity
These don’t produce daily sellable profits. So how do funds pay tax on paper gains?
Some options:
Sell assets (at the wrong time).
Borrow (but at what cost?).
Reduce member benefits (unintended hit).
It’s not just unfair — it’s unworkable.
The Tax That Keeps Growing
📆 2025: 80,000 Australians affected
📆 2045: 400,000 estimated
📆 2065: 1.6–2 million
Why?
No indexation = bracket creep
Compounding = growth over time
Inheritances = late-life super boosts
Soon, this isn’t a tax on the rich — it’s a mainstream tax on ordinary workers.
What Could Happen Next
Option A: Labor gets re-elected. Division 296 becomes law July 2025.
Option B: Coalition gains power. The tax is shelved.
Option C: Greens get their way. Threshold drops to $2m.
The stakes are high — and the real fight is for the integrity of the super system.
Better Alternatives
If the government wants fairness in super, here are some less destructive options:
Index the Threshold: Keep pace with inflation.
Tax Only Realised Gains: The standard global approach.
Improve Tax Reporting, Not Policy: Focus on closing loopholes.
Cap Concessional Tax Benefits, Not Balances: Treat the behaviour, not the balance.
What It Means for You, Your Kids, and Australia
This tax isn’t just about the next few years. It’s about the next few decades.
Do you want your kids penalised for saving diligently?
Do you want retirees punished for investment volatility?
Do you want superannuation to become another tax trap?
If the answer is no, then Division 296 must be opposed — not because it affects some rich people today, but because it hurts all of us tomorrow.
What You Can Do
Educate Yourself: Understand how the tax works.
Talk to Your Adviser: Strategic planning may become essential.
Vote Smart: Policies matter more than ever.
Share the Message: Most Australians don’t know they’re the target — yet.
Super should reward good habits — not punish them.
Division 296 breaks that promise.
Newcastle Advisors is here to help you make sense of the noise and protect your financial future. If this article raised concerns about your retirement, now’s the time to act.
Matthew McCabe, Expert Financial Planner at Newcastle Advisors
unrealised capital gains tax
Division 296 tax
superannuation tax Australia
$3 million super tax
taxing unrealised gains
Labor super policy
how Division 296 affects you
financial planner Newcastle